RaMBa”N). Sha’ar HaGemul [“The Gate of Reward:” A Treatise on the Afterlife]
AUCTION 26 |
Monday, November 22nd,
2004 at 1:00
Exceptional Printed Books, Sixty-Five Hebrew Incunabula: The Elkan Nathan Adler-Wineman Family Collection
Lot 37
MOSES BEN NACHMAN (NACHMANIDES).
RaMBa”N). Sha’ar HaGemul [“The Gate of Reward:” A Treatise on the Afterlife]
(Naples): Joseph ben Jacob Aschkenazi Gunzenhauser (1490)
Est: $20,000 - $25,000
PRICE REALIZED $24,000
Sha’ar HaGemul is but a single section (the thirtieth chapter) of Nachmanides’ comprehensive halachic work on death and mourning, Torath Ha’Adam. Because of its philosophical significance, this section merited a separate edition, printed almost thirty years before the remainder of the work in Constantinople, 1519 (See Kestenbaum & Company, Important Hebrew Printed Books, October 2004, Lot 42).
In Sha’ar HaGemul, Nachmanides takes exception to Maimonides’ portrayal of the Afterlife. In Maimonides’ view, the Messianic era (yemoth ha-mashiach), which is very much this-worldly, is followed by a wholly spiritual Afterlife. Nachmanides’ scheme is diametrically opposed, with “olam ha-ba,” the World to Come, posing a temporary reality, followed by the ultimate Messianic state of affairs, which as said, constitutes a harmonious balance of body and soul. Chasidic philosophy, especially the teachings of Chabad Chassidism, opted for Nachmanides’ eschatology. See EJ, Vol. XII, cols. 781-2