Sepher Mitzvath Gadol [Sema”g: Great Book of Precepts]

AUCTION 26 | Monday, November 22nd, 2004 at 1:00
Exceptional Printed Books, Sixty-Five Hebrew Incunabula: The Elkan Nathan Adler-Wineman Family Collection

Back to Catalogue Download Catalogue

Lot 5
MOSES BEN JACOB OF COUCY

Sepher Mitzvath Gadol [Sema”g: Great Book of Precepts]

FIRST EDITION. Two volumes, both complete. Printed in double columns. Marginalia in a beautiful Ma’aravic mashait script (cf. EJ, Vol. II, col. 734, fig. 13). For example, see Vol. I, front blank, ff.12r., 37r.; Vol II, f. 212v. Other marginalia in an Aschkenazic cursive script (see Vol. II, f.195v.) The D.S. Sassoon Copy (purchase, 1969). A WIDE-MARGINED COPY Vol. I: ff. (175). Vol. II: ff. (98). Several leaves laid to size with some loss of text: (see Vol I: first three leaves and final leaf; Volume II: see opening two leaves). Wormed and stained in places. Modern blind-tooled calf. Folio Vinograd, Rome 2; Goff 84; Goldstein 7; Offenberg 94; Steinschneider, p. 1796, no. 6453, 1; Thesaurus A19; Wineman Cat. 5a. No copy in Cambridge University

(Rome: Printer unknown 1469-72)

Est: $150,000 - $200,000
PRICE REALIZED $230,000
COMPLETE TWO-VOLUME COPY OF THE EDITIO PRINCEPS OF SEPHER MITZVOTH GADOL. The fonts of this incunable are somewhat smaller in size than the other Roman incunabula, with a more advanced lay-out, together with a woodcut. Rabbi Moses of Coucy (13th century) here followed Maimonides’ general arrangement of the precepts, dividing the 613 commandments into 248 positive commandments and 365 negative commandments. The introduction to the second volume of the Sema"g, on negative commandments, is especially rich. In it, the author traces the origin and development of the Oral Law, from the tannaitic period of the Mishnah, to the amoraic period of the Talmud, followed by R. Yehudai Gaon’s Halachoth Gedoloth, R. Isaac Alfasi’s Halachoth and the crowning achievement of Maimonides - which brings him up to date. As magnificent as is the edifice of Maimonides’ Code, it leaves much to be desired. First, Maimonides provides no sources for his legal decisions, making his book “like a dream without interpretation.” Second, the great French authorities of the school of Rashi disagree with Maimonides’ understanding of the Halacha in many areas. This necessitated the drafting of a new compendium in consonance with the teachings of Rashi and his School. States Moses of Coucy: “At the beginning of the sixth millenium (1240 C.E.) there came to me in a dream: ‘Rise up, compose a Sepher Torah of two sections.’” This he interpreted as a charge to compose this Book of Commandments divided into positive and negative precepts. Subsequently, when R. Moses completed the work, he had a second dream in which there appeared to him the verse, “Be heedful lest you forget the Lord your God.” R. Moses interpreted this as a Divine instruction to include in the roster of negative commandments the prohibition against forgetting the Deity (a prohibition left unenumerated by his predecessor Maimonides)